Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

Section
Column
width33%
Panel
borderColor#003366
bgColor#fff
titleBGColor#ccc
titleStruts Subproject
borderStylesolid
Pros
  • An interested community already exists
  • The active developers are already committers here
  • The uninvolved committers are already familiar with the project and codebase
  • The PMC already knows the software.
Cons
  • We do not want Struts to be conceived as an umbrella project.
  • The move would be temporary
Column
width33%
Panel
borderColor#ccc
bgColor#fff
titleBGColor#ccc
titleJakarta Commons
borderStylesolid
Pros
  • Allows Tiles to grow independent of struts while at the same time having community support.
Cons
  • The majority of the jakarta community is unfamiliar with the codebase
  • It does not seem to fit with the other subprojects since it is a web component
Column
width33%
Panel
borderColor#ccc
bgColor#fff
titleBGColor#ccc
titleTop Level Project
borderStylesolid
Pros
  • Stresses the independence of the tiles codebase from Struts.
Cons
  • It is undetermined how the community will accept a standalone tiles and thus how much staying power there is.
  • While the quota of 3 actives committers/pms members can be found, it seems as though we are one or two committers short of a healthy stand along community.
  • The active members would like to have a little more time to get the community established

Community Involvement

At least three committers are required to +1 any release in order to maintain an active community. These have been identified:

...