Delete comments <a href="http://www.aptis.info/portfolio/delete-all-comments/" target="_blank" title="Help"> <span class="aui-icon aui-icon-small aui-iconfont-help aptis-delete-all-comments-title-icon">Help</span> </a>

Mark, I think you've captured the core features i'd like to see. Under Im...

Dan Bress | Jul 31, 2015

Dan, I could easily see a template leveraging components in multiple nars. It...

Joe Witt | Aug 09, 2015

Joe, Good point. I didn't think about the multiple nar thing, but thats a ...

Dan Bress | Aug 11, 2015

I do believe that if we get this right when a template is imported all necessar...

Joe Witt | Aug 11, 2015

If we have a cluster of NiFi Servers, how can we push the artifact (_nar_) to o...

Puspendu Banerjee | May 04, 2016

The node on the cluster is no different then any other node in that same cluste...

Oleg Zhurakousky | May 05, 2016

Agreed, we are at very early stage of this discussion, still my intent here was...

Puspendu Banerjee | May 05, 2016

Yep. Good idea Puspendu.

Joe Witt | May 05, 2016

Based on the number of files those are being affected, to avoid flooding mai...

Puspendu Banerjee | May 09, 2016

joewitt , mattf or anyone got a chance to look at the extension registry implem...

Puspendu Banerjee | Jun 04, 2016

Added Maven based Artifact(nar) Resolver support. So technically one can pass G...

Puspendu Banerjee | Jun 09, 2016

Hi puspendu.banerjee@gmail.com, I'm new to NiFi, but I'll share the thoughts I ...

Matthew Foley | Jun 10, 2016

Upon re-reading this, I see that I am using "nar" as synonymous with "Processor...

Matthew Foley | Jun 10, 2016

Hi mattf! Thanks for reviewing. Let me address your valuable comments/concerns:...

Puspendu Banerjee | Jun 10, 2016

puspendu.banerjee@gmail.com, thanks for your very fast response! As you sugges...

Matthew Foley | Jun 12, 2016

mattf ,Thanks for your passion to get it going. The only challenge with yum / ...

Puspendu Banerjee | Jun 12, 2016

Ok, those are good reasons to question use of yum as an example file-based repo...

Matthew Foley | Jun 14, 2016

mattf & joewitt : I have created a sample registry repo [ maven layout] at http...

Puspendu Banerjee | Jun 10, 2016

As you point out, we need an "official" Apache NiFi repository, where all the e...

Matthew Foley | Jun 12, 2016

I think, starting it under current nifi tree will reduce some paperwork but wil...

Puspendu Banerjee | Jun 12, 2016

Yes, we need signatures and signing certificates. Are nar's currently signed? ...

Matthew Foley | Jun 14, 2016

Looking at puspendu.banerjee@gmail.com's very useful reference implementation i...

Matthew Foley | Jun 14, 2016

puspendu.banerjee@gmail.com and I have been exchanging ideas about design, and ...

Matthew Foley | Jun 30, 2016

The Use Cases and Design Proposal (above, in the main body of this wiki page) a...

Matthew Foley | Jul 01, 2016

i don't think the multiple instances create thing is worth mentioning for the p...

Joe Witt | Jul 11, 2016

as written this makes it look like 3P vendors cannot participate at all. What ...

Joe Witt | Jul 11, 2016

facilitating adoption is good of course but the primary driver is right-sized d...

Joe Witt | Jul 11, 2016

ideally it is tied solely to a version of the 'nifi-api' because for extensions...

Joe Witt | Jul 11, 2016

how about 'ExtensionRepository'

Joe Witt | Jul 11, 2016

Sure

Matthew Foley | Jul 11, 2016

Done. Prototype code will follow shortly.

Matthew Foley | Jul 11, 2016

keeping in mind that a single NAR can have a parent NAR and we'd need to pull b...

Joe Witt | Jul 11, 2016

Good point. WIth a Maven repo, it is easily supported to pull the dependencies...

Matthew Foley | Jul 11, 2016

Elaborated several sections on dependencies, mostly in the ExtensionRepository ...

Matthew Foley | Jul 11, 2016

Makes sense for extension artifacts but for templates we will want to show the ...

Joe Witt | Jul 11, 2016

We tried to draw a line between "metadata", which is brief and could fit in a P...

Matthew Foley | Jul 11, 2016

Added optional adoc file to section B (with mention in section A). We can spli...

Matthew Foley | Jul 11, 2016

Added this note, in response to a terminology question.

Matthew Foley | Jul 11, 2016

Will a template also have the dependency information of needed NARs? Another t...

Aldrin Piri | Jul 12, 2016

Keeping dependency hierarchy managed maven will keep things cleaner. Eventually...

Puspendu Banerjee | Jul 12, 2016

This proposed feature description was written much earlier than Sections 5 and ...

Matthew Foley | Jul 12, 2016

(continued) only if the needed dependencies are available in either the same re...

Matthew Foley | Jul 12, 2016

Should provided flexibility to have ordered registries. Consider a system wher...

Aldrin Piri | Jul 12, 2016

Are there any specific semantics of XML? I ask this because with the developin...

Aldrin Piri | Jul 12, 2016

Template files are already XMLs. This proposes that these XML files could be u...

Matthew Foley | Jul 12, 2016

Completely agree on that. What I am more interested is how these items are han...

Aldrin Piri | Jul 12, 2016

Hi aldrin, thanks for this and all your inputs. With respect, it sounds to me ...

Matthew Foley | Jul 12, 2016

mattf & aldrin thanks for your inputs. We should take the note and likely addin...

Puspendu Banerjee | Jul 12, 2016

Hey mattf, I think we are on the same page. As mentioned, I was not asking fo...

Aldrin Piri | Jul 13, 2016

Would it make sense to use a system scope in the Maven file for local dependenc...

Aldrin Piri | Jul 12, 2016

Could you please elaborate. Based on current implementation a maven resolver wi...

Puspendu Banerjee | Jul 12, 2016

Ah, gotcha. That clarifies. When I had originally read it, I thought it was r...

Aldrin Piri | Jul 12, 2016

You welcome. Additionally, the added advantage is to add new maven compatible ...

Puspendu Banerjee | Jul 12, 2016

Delete comments Help