...
The pull request process is driven by a pull request shepherd.
Shepherds are Flink committers that voluntarily sign up and *feel responsible* for helping the PR through the process until it is merged (or discarded).
The shepherd is also the person to contact for the author of the PR. It is preferable if the
IMPORTANT: Everybody (contributors and committers) is encouraged to discuss all pull requests, give feedback, and (in case of committers) merge pull requests which are in a good shape.
However, the shepherd should feel responsible to drive a PR forward if nothing happens.
Phases of a Pull Request
- Getting a Shepherd:
Each pull request is taken care of by a shepherd.
A committer becomes the shepherd of a PR by commenting the PR on Github like “I “I would like to shepherd this PR”PR”.
A PR can be reassigned with lazy consensus. - Being Accepted:
The first decision for a PR should be whether it is accepted or not.
This depends on:- whether it is a desired feature or improvement for Flink and
- whether the higher-level solution design is appropriate.
In case of a PR that proposes a complex feature, the discussion should have been started when the mandatory JIRA was created (see our code contribution guide).
If it is not clear whether the PR should be accepted or not, a discussion should be started in the corresponding JIRA issue (a JIRA issue needs to be created if none exists).
The acceptance decision should be recorded by a “+1 to accept” PR accepted” comment in Github. This can be done by any committer (not necessarily the shepherd).
If the PR is not accepted, it The PR should be closed in a timely manner if it is not accepted. - Becoming Ready to be Merged
Once a PR has been “accepted”, it should needs to be brought into a mergeable state. This means the community should quickly react on contributor questions or PR updates.
Everybody is encouraged to review pull requests and give feedback.
Ideally, the PR author does not have to wait for a long time to get feedback.
The shepherd of a PR should feel responsible to drive this process forward.
Once the PR is considered to be mergeable, this should be recorded by a “+1 to merge” PR good to merge” message in Github. This can be done by any committer (not necessarily the shepherd).
If the pull request becomes abandoned at some point in time, it should be either taken over by somebody else or be closed after a reasonable time.
Again, this can be done by anybody, but the shepherd should feel responsible to resolve the issue. - Being Merged
Once, the PR is in a mergeable state, it should be merged.
This can be done by anybody, however the shepherd should make sure that it happens in a timely manner.
IMPORTANT: Everybody is encouraged to discuss pull requests, give feedback, and merge pull requests which are in a good shape. However, the shepherd should feel responsible to drive a PR forward if nothing happens Discussions should happen primarily on Github. If the discussion is moved to JIRA or the development mailing list, we must make sure that the PR author is aware of that (i.e., follows the JIRA issue or is subscribed to the mailing list).
Taking a Shortcut
--- Matthias Sax
...