Frequently Asked Questions
1.1. Where's the archive for the list?
Currently, Gmane holds the messages of the last two weeks. This service also makes the mailing list reachable with a news reader.
You can use the ezmlm mailing list controller to receive previous messages by email. Send an empty email to dev-helpATsantuario.apache.org for detailed information on how to use this service.
2. Required background
2.1. Where can I learn about XML?
2.2. Where can I learn about XML Digital Signatures?
The best place to start is W3C XML-Signature Syntax and Processing.
2.3. Where can I learn about XML Encryption?
The best place to start is W3C XML Encryption Syntax and Processing.
2.4. Where can I learn about Cryptography in general?
A lot of resources exist on the web, including the 'green bible' for cryptography: Handbook of Applied Cryptography. The Handbook of Applied Cryptography is completely online and it should satisfy most of your cryptographic hunger. Disadvantage of it is that it goes rather deep, so it isn't a executive overview or a "Learn XYZ in 21 days"-book.
3. XMLDSig questions
3.1. What is the enveloped transform?
The enveloped transform is a special transform that enables the use of so-called enveloped signatures.
Enveloped signatures are signatures over an entire XML document, for which the <Signature> element is included in the document itself. An example could be:
The Reference indicates that Root and it's descendants (except for comments) are signed, but the Transform element says to throw out the Signature element (that is the parent of this Reference) from the stream that is to be signed. Note that if there are other Signature elements in Root, they will remain untouched.
3.2. What's the difference between C14N and ExclC14N?
C14N was introduced to solve some problems that arise when signing XML. Because XML allows to change the representation of an XML document without changing the actual content, signatures may break when different parsers are used to generate and verify the signature. A simple example of such an allowed change is changing the order of attributes within an element. (That is solved by C14N by sorting the attributes by alphabet)
Because a C14N'ed XML fragment inherits all the namespace declarations from it's ancestors, it is not possible to embed a signed XML fragment into a document that has other namespace declarations.
This is solved by ExclC14N. ExclC14N takes extra information as input in which you can specify which of the ancestor's namespaces should be included.
For more information on this topic, have a look at the C14N and ExclC14N sections of the W3C XMLDSig WG.
4. Secure Validation
A property was added in the 1.5.0 release to enable "secure validation". This property is true by default from the 2.3.0 release, but false for earlier releases. When set to true, it enforces the following processing rules:
- Limits the number of Transforms per Reference to a maximum of 5.
- Does not allow XSLT transforms.
- Does not allow a RetrievalMethod to reference another RetrievalMethod.
- Does not allow a Reference to call the ResolverLocalFilesystem or the ResolverDirectHTTP (references to local files and HTTP resources are forbidden).
- Limits the number of references per Manifest (SignedInfo) to a maximum of 30.
- MD5 is not allowed as a SignatureAlgorithm or DigestAlgorithm.
- Guarantees that the Dereferenced Element returned via Document.getElementById is unique by performing a tree-search.
- 1.5.6 Does not allow DTDs
This functionality is supported in the core library through additional method signatures which take a boolean, and in the JSR-105 API via the property "org.apache.jcp.xml.dsig.secureValidation, e.g.:
Secure Validation should be enabled in production as otherwise various attacks might be possible